Review: “Wasgij Imagine #1: If the Conservatives Win the General Election”

jigsawjunkie_wasgijimagine1

Publisher: Jumbo (Netherlands), published Jan 2015

Title:  “Wasgij Imagine #1: If the Conservatives Win the General Election”, Artist: Neil Easton 1000 pieces 

OUR RATING: 7.8/10

It was a rather exciting announcement when Jumbo gave us a look at a new Wasgij series called “Imagine”. The fact that they felt confident enough in it to release three different puzzles as part of the “#1” release in the series certainly peaked my curiosity.

The concept of the three puzzle set called “#1 General Election” is simple. The three boxes share the same image on the lid. And each puzzle has a puzzle image that is a “what if” scenario: “What if the Conservatives won the general election” , “What if the Labour won the general election”, and “What if the Liberal Democrats won the general election”?

Here’s my review of the “Conservatives” edition of this puzzle.

Box Quality: (9/10)

The Jumbo box is sturdy and very attractively designed. You can see the front above. The back tells us more about the concept behind the puzzle.

jigsawjunkie_wasgijimagine2

Sides:

The sides of the box focus on the image and the “Wasigj” logo. I’m glad they have the “Imagine” and “#1” on the sides since those really help when shelving the series.  The artist really isn’t touted much on this box. In the fine print on one short side is says the artist’s name is Neil Easton.

jigsawjunkie_wasgijimagine3

Inside:

Inside the box is a bag with the puzzle pieces (in excellent condition, no damage, puzzle dust, or unseparated pieces). There’s nothing else in this box. There are some pictures of other puzzles in the Wasgij line printed on the inside of the bottom.

jigsawjunkie_wasgijimagine4

Puzzle Quality: (9.5)

You can see my Jumbo brand comparison here.  To sum: Jumbo is an excellent brand. The pieces are good-sized and thick and the image reproduction is excellent. The pieces have a grid cut, but there’s a nice variety of piece shapes. You never think a piece fits where it does not. The surface has a linen like finish that feels nice and is non-reflective. This puzzle is no exception to that usual high quality.

The Image: (5)

My hope for this 3-puzzle series went something like this: each puzzle image would be a take on what England would be like if that party won the election. For example, a London street with conservatives ruling vs the same London street with hippies ruling the day, etc.  Perhaps some clever visual references to various policies each party had promised. What I was hoping it wouldn’t be was images of British political celebrities whom I didn’t know as a non-Brit.

Unfortunately, the puzzle image is the latter. The puzzle scene is a simple outdoor scene with a number of politicians holding a small celebration. The bulk of the image consists of caricatures of real life politicians, up close and in simple poses. The background of this scene is very basic – a bit of a wall of a castle or manor and some greenery.

Compared to images like “What If: Dinosaurs Still Rules the World” (here’s my review), which showed several streets and a park (with various characters), this puzzle image is very simplistic.  It could have been made interesting even to those who don’t follow British politics by widening the view and having more going on in the picture—more detail, more design, more colors, more sight gags. Unfortunately, that wasn’t done.

Not to sound ignorant, but as an American, the only people I’m really familiar with in British politics are the royal family and prime minister. Of course, we do hear about big issues over here, like gay marriage, the Scotland independence vote, etc, but we’re not privy to the finer details of the British political parties. So the people in the image were not familiar to me at all. Of course, with the internet anyone could follow British politics closely, I suppose, but probably doesn’t. In fact, I wonder how many Brits follow it that closely.

I’ve included a few detail close-ups of the image in this review. You can see the entire image at the link below if you don’t plan to purchase the puzzle and/or don’t mind a huge spoiler.

(Click here to see the final puzzle image. ****WARNING: This is a spoiler if you intend to do the puzzle.****)

wasgij_imagine_1_ConservativesWin_CU1_SM

Assembly:  (8)

What I enjoy about wasgij puzzles is that you need to take a different approach for assembly because you don’t know what the final image is going to be. So I usually do the border first and then look for colors and patterns that are similar and put those together in groups. As you get more and more of these small areas complete, you start to see how they interconnect and you can move them around until you have enough done to lock down the final image.

Another thing I didn’t particularly like about this puzzle image was that there weren’t enough variety of colors and patterns. Nearly all the characters are in blue. Generally there’s more variety than this in wasgij issues. It wasn’t a particularly hard puzzle to assemble, and still fun, but a little bland compared to other wasgijs.

wasgij_imagine_1_ConservativesWin_CU2_SM

Conclusion:

I remain a big fan of wasgij puzzles. But if you’re not a follower of British politics, there are better and more interesting Wasgij puzzles to get. I’d suggest the first two in the “What If?” series – “What if Money Grew on Trees” and “What if Dinosaurs Still Roamed the Earth”, both of which are outstanding puzzles. Or any of the recent Wasgij Original, Mystery, Destiny, or Christmas series releases, for that matter.

It’s my understanding that Jumbo has terminated the “What If” series (probably due to a legal conflict with Ravensburger’s “What If”) and will be calling it “Imagine” moving forward. This was just the first release of that new series. I look forward to more releases and hope they are more similar to the first two “What If” releases by Jumbo.

Final Score:

jigsawjunkie_wasgijimagine5

Where to find:

Amazon.co.uk

JJ

 

7 responses to Review: “Wasgij Imagine #1: If the Conservatives Win the General Election”

  1. Scottish Jen says:

    What a disappointment for you, Jane. This was an apparently clever concept with a lot of potential to make some interesting political or social commentary in the scenes depicted. I mean, come on, they could have really gone to town on that front, for all three political parties (i.e.remaining politically neutral)! Maybe the lawyers knocked that idea on the head, who knows. The end product is bland and uninspiring though and feels like an interesting opportunity missed. Oh, and as a Brit who watches the BBC news nightly, I can’t name all of these people either.

    • Interesting to hear that from a Brit. I am curious how well people who live in the UK will like the puzzle. It’s not terrible just, as you say, a missed opportunity. I will always be a big wasgij fan though! I really adored the first two “What Ifs?”. I also like the idea of a 3-puzzle set with different scenarios. As you say, just a missed opportunity here for something far more universal.

      • Scottish Jen says:

        I need to try my first Wasgij soon. I have a couple waiting in my TBD pile but somehow I have a mental block about completing a puzzle without an image to follow. They look great fun though, especially the dinosaurs puzzle that you reviewed. I have one of the new ones, the scene of the kids running amok in the nursery, and I think I’ll start with that one.

      • That looks like a good one too. It’s not too hard to build a wasgij as there are usually good areas of color and pattern you can put together. I quite like that it’s a slightly different process but I don’t find it that much harder really. Good luck!

  2. Mike W says:

    I think, that you have to review these three as a set. As a Brit, who is living in Texas, for the last 8 years, I probably couldn’t name most of the characters too, but since I have these to build, so far, I have resisted temptation to click the full preview.

    If it is some kind of outdoor scene, I suspect, the outside of a country manor for the Conservatives, a Working Men’s Club for Labour, and something like a music festival / camp ground for the Liberals. Very stereo-typical. That’s my expectations. I have a feeling you were expecting something more like Mike Jupp’s I love London… but in blue.

    Possibly, look past the whole picture, and look at the characters in that picture. the cigar smoking man, the name on the drink bottle, both look and sound Conservative to me.

    It looks like the image didn’t meet your expectations… You wanted a Conservative victory parade in Trafalgar Square ? but, up and down Britain, on Election Night, and into the next day, the scenes described above, are far more common.

    • Well, I’ll be interested to hear your opinion when you complete them. I found the puzzle image pretty dull for a wasgij image, regardless of subject matter, in terms of the amount of detail, color, and sight gags. To me, the final image really isn’t interesting unless you know the people who are in it. Even if it was a celebration party at a manor, more detail and interest could have been added to it. But yeah, it will be interesting to see what others think.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s