Review: “Who did It?” by Michael Ryba, Heye, 2000 pieces – 10/10

heye_wdi_boxwposterjpg

Publisher: Heye (Germany), published 1998 and currently reissued in a rectangular box

Title:  “Who Did It?”, Artist: Michael Ryba, 2000 pieces 

OUR RATING: 10/10

I worked this puzzle years ago, but it was time, over the lengthy holidays, to get it out again. This has long been one of my favorite Heye puzzles. I love Ryba’s cartoon art, and I love the ‘faux scary’ cartoon themes (others are Loup’s “Castle of Horror” and Prades “Walpurgis Night”). I’m a big murder mystery fan and a Heye fan, so this puzzle is the best of all possible worlds for me. I also like the size. 2000 pieces is just enough to make for a significantly longer and ‘chunkier’ puzzling experience than my usual 1000 piece puzzle, but it’s not endless. This time I will preserve the completed puzzle using my temporary mounting system so I see the full assembled puzzle anytime I want.

Box Quality:

As readers of my blog know, I love the Heye triangular boxes. It’s a fun shape that shelves well in pairs of two. They just feel more “special” than the rectangular boxes, and the quality of them is great–colorful, fun, and sturdy in the German board game tradition. This original version of “Who Did It?” from 1998 is in the triangular box shown above and below. (Click on any picture in this review to get a larger photo.)

heye_wdi_boxside

The back side shows the entire picture and has information about the artist and puzzle.

heye_wdi_boxback

 

Top:

The older Heye triangular boxes had black plastic caps which were only held on by the shrink wrap. These are super annoying since they come off and get lost behind the shelves once you have opened a puzzle. The later triangular boxes have an attached top with a graphic of the puzzle, which is a big improvement. However, this 1998 puzzle box has the old black top.

heye_wdi_boxlid

Bottom:

The bottom has copyright and other retail info.

heye_wdi_boxbottom

 

Inside:

Inside the box is a bag with the puzzle pieces and a large poster of the image on thick paper.  You can see the front and back of the poster below. The back of this poster has a ‘solution’ to the murder mystery in the image. I’ve blurred it out to prevent spoilers.  I doubt this poster is included in the newer rectangular reissue (“Crime Scene”). The solution on the back isn’t the sort of thing you can “guess” from looking at the puzzle. It’s more like an extra little story that goes along with the image. It’s printed in four languages. [Click here to see the back of the puzzle without the blur–spoilers included.]

I always use the Heye posters quite a lot while I’m working the puzzle because with the high level of detail, you need to refer to the image often and it’s much nicer with the large poster than trying to work with the box.

heye_wdi_posterfront heye_wdi_posterback

 

The Image:

As I said above, I adore this image. It’s a spoof on murder mysteries. Each little scene in the puzzle has many threats from daggers, to knights with axes, to bottles of poison, saws, etc. And it’s all set in a spooky old castle.  (Click on any of the images in this review for a closer look.)

Heye_WhoDidIt_main_800

Puzzle Quality:

You can see my Heye brand comparison here for details.  To sum: Heye is one of my favorite brands, mainly because of their awesome cartoon puzzles and overall German quality. Although Heye has a standard grid cut, there’s lots of variety in the piece shapes, as you can see in the close-up below. The pieces feel thick and have a nice, linen, non-glare finish to the pieces. The fit of this 1998 puzzle is slightly loose, so it’s difficult to move pieces without them falling apart. However, there is never any question about whether a piece fits or not (unlike Gibson and Educa). The piece fit is very specific.

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU4_800

Assembly:  

“Who Did It?” is definitely a challenge. There are lots of yellows/golds and greens in the picture. I assembled the border first, then the frames of the magnifying glasses. This helped separate the main areas/vignettes within the puzzle. I used the poster to check individual puzzle pieces quite often to see where they went. But the little figures have different outfits and expression, so it isn’t difficult to tell where each piece goes. The puzzle wasn’t frustrating since there aren’t large areas of similar color/texture.

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU6_800

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU5_800

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU8_800

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU3_800

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU2_800

Heye_WhoDidIt_CU7_800

Conclusion:

“Who Did It?” is a classic Heye that’s a must have for all cartoon puzzle lovers.  It’s been republished by Heye as part of their Cartoon Classics (still in 2000 pieces) in a rectangular box under the name “Crime Scene”. You can see it here on Puzzle Warehouse. Grab it before it goes out of print again!

If you prefer the older triangular box version, your best bet is ebay. Be sure to look for international sellers because the Heyes come up most often on German ebay.

On a sad note, Michael Ryba unfortunately was killed in a car accident a few years ago.  Such a great loss for his family and fans! But for his jigsaw puzzle fans sake, I hope he had some artwork not published previously that Heye could make into new puzzles. Also there are also some great older Ryba images I’d like to see reissued (such as “Fire Brigade”, “Big Attack”, “Amazonas”, “New York”, “Holiday On Ice”, “Surfing in Heaven”). Please, Heye!

JJ

9 responses to Review: “Who did It?” by Michael Ryba, Heye, 2000 pieces – 10/10

  1. Mike W says:

    Hi Jane – Can you post a linked image of the back of the poster, so that those of us with the box, and not the triangle,. can see who did it, please ?!

    • I updated the review with a link to the unblurred poster. I had to make it quite large to be able to read the story.

  2. Ivy C says:

    I only recently got back into puzzling after visiting my FIL in hospital and there were a few boxes of jigsaws in the common room for patients. It took two visits for the family to finish a 500pc puzzle but I am hooked once again. Came home and jumped online to see what was on offer and found your site. I bought Crime Scene along with Loup’s Apocalyspe and Castle of Horrors based on your reviews. I am now a new fan of both artist ( I am hoping to find Ryba’s Romantic Town. Do you own this puzzle? and if yes, I hope you will do a review) back to crime scene,I am slightly disappointed that the 2006 version excludes the poster but hopefully the picture on the box is sufficient to refer to. Thank you for such an in depth review. Looking forward to starting these puzzles in the holidays.

    • Hi, Ivy! Welcome back to the world of puzzling. 🙂 I do have an old copy of Ryba’s Romantic Town but I bought it used. Hopefully when I get to it, it has all it’s pieces! It would be a good one for Heye to reissue. I’m not positive that the rectangular box reissues don’t include a poster, but I’m guessing they don’t. Please post and let us know how you enjoy your experience with these puzzles.

  3. Ivy C says:

    Just an update, I’ve completed the reissue of this puzzle. my husband took care of the kids while I worked ferociously to finish it. After 2 and a half days I came out of seclusion to find the house an absolute wreck and the kids having jam sandwiches for dinner. I can confirm there is no poster, which is a shame. The box picture was a little small to work with (not much fine detail) and there is a logo at the bottom of the box obscuring part of the picture. The fit is quite loose like you said. And it was harder than I imagined. But all in all I enjoyed it although I might have overdone it and now I need to rest my eyes and back before takling another 2000 piece. Cheers

    • Great! Thankis for the report on the reissue (rectangular box) and lack of poster. You have a good husband, fyi. 🙂

  4. Michael says:

    I chanced upon your site while looking for this puzzle. Just finished Fairy Tales from Heye and the big poster is a must have! But for 2006 Crime Scene, there is no poster? Any idea why did Heye stopped printing poster ? It’s so inconvenient to be referring to the box especially for 2000 pcs.

    • Hi, Michael. Heye releases cartoon puzzles in a few different types of packaging. Their triangular boxes include a puzzle. They also reissue older cartoon puzzles in regular rectangular boxes under the “Cartoon Classics” labels. The ones in the rectangular boxes don’t have a poster. So if you find “Who Did It?” in a triangular box, it should have a poster.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s