Review: “Sherlock and Co” by Gobel and Knorr, Heye 10/10

Heye_Sherlock&Co_box

Publisher: Heye (Germany)

Title:  “Sherlock and Co” by Doro Gobel and Peter Knorr, Heye, 2000 pieces

Released Jan 2016

Review by Jane

OUR RATING: 10/10

Box Quality:  (10/10)
I have a thing for Heye triangular boxes, and I’m happy every year to add to my collection of them. Pretty much, if it’s in a Heye triangular box, I will get it. This year (2016) the boxes are as good as ever and, in fact, include more goodies inside the box than in previous years.

The box has an attractive closer view of the image on the two front sides and on the top, along with the name of the puzzle, artist, piece count, and Heye logo. The back of the box shows the full image.

Heye_Sherlock&Co_boxback

The top of the box has a close-up detail from the image, the piece count, and the Heye logo. This is ideal for shelving top-out, as I do with these triangular boxes. You can see my Heye shelf here.

Heye_Sherlock&Co_boxtop

Inside:

Inside the boxes this year we have the very large poster, with pictures of other puzzles available in the 2016 line on the back. In addition, there is a guarantee card and a mini catalogue. Nice! Years from now, it’s wonderful to have this record of the other puzzles released at the same time so you can see what they were and track them down if desired.

Heye_Sherlock&Co_boxgoodies1

Below is the poster front and back:

Heye_Sherlock&Co_poster

Heye_Sherlock&Co_poster2

 

The Image: 10/10

I’m a huge fan of BBC Sherlock (no, really). It’s been my number 1 show since the first season aired and I’m pretty active in the Tumblr fan community. So the idea of having BBC Sherlock + Heye is sort of a geeky fangirl dream.

The image definitely appears to be BBC Sherlock specific, judging by the Sherlock Holmes and John Watson depicted in the puzzle (they look like Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman).

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CUSHERLOCK_web

The image shows a vast cityscape with various characters. There are a number of police bobbies in the scene, looking for clues, people looking out windows or on the decks of the houses, and people on the street.

It’s a complex image that you discover as you assemble the puzzle. I like the art style too. Absolutely full marks from me.

Heye_Sherlock&Co_main_web

Above: The completed puzzle. Click for closer view.

Puzzle Quality: 9/10

The quality of Heye puzzles is very good. The pieces have gotten a little larger in the last few years, and they are about the same size and thickness as Ravensburger.  It’s a grid-cut puzzle, but has quite a lot of variation in piece shape, as you can see in the close-up below. There’s never a problem of a piece seeming to fit where it doesn’t actually go.

The only reason it scores a 9 instead of a 10 for me is that the fit is not particularly tight. You need to use caution when moving groups of assembled pieces around and you can’t lift the edge of the puzzle without it falling apart. Still, the final finish is flat and relatively seamless.

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU3_web

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU6_web

Assembly: 10/10
This puzzle is difficult to assemble but not frustrating. I started with the border and then the pink/red buildings. The building in the lower left that has the scaffolding on it is also fairly recognizable so you can easily pull out the pieces. There are a ton of buildings in the image though, some of which have the same or similar colors. There are lots of similar details sprinkled throughout, like the bobbies in black and the brick chimneys, which require you to really study the image and the piece to see where it goes.

Slow and steady wins the race, as they say. A 2000 piece puzzle like this isn’t designed to be completed in a day, but it’s nice to have a longer ‘project’ from time to time. I really enjoyed seeing the details in the image, like footprints, and the various characters, as the puzzle progressed. As I said, there was no one area that was particularly hard or frustrating, and it was clear where everything went once you looked at the poster. If you like bigger and/or a more time-consuming puzzling experience, you’ll enjoy this one. I did!

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU2_web

Additional Images:

 

 

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU5_web

 

 

 

 

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU4_web

Heye_Sherlock&Co_CU8_web

Heye_Sherlock&Co_left_upper_web

Bonus Points

I gave this puzzle 1 bonus point for being related to BBC Sherlock and not being just photographs of the actors’ faces, like so many licensed puzzles are. I love the fact that this is an original, hand-drawn image related to BBC Sherlock and designed to be a perfect puzzle for Heye!

Conclusion

This is my favorite of the new Heye releases this year, which pretty much puts it at the top of the 2016 best puzzles list!  I recommend it to anyone who thinks they’re up to a 2000 piece challenge!

Heye_Sherlock_RF

 

Where to find:

It’s now up on Amazon UK for a very reasonable price.  It’s also on ebay from various sellers. In the US, Puzzle Warehouse and Jigsaw Jungle both carry Heye puzzles, though they don’t have the new 2016 puzzles in stock at the time of this writing.

JJ

2 responses to Review: “Sherlock and Co” by Gobel and Knorr, Heye 10/10

  1. kimscheinberg says:

    That’s roughly $32 if ordered from the UK, plus shipping. It’s closer to $22 from puzzle-portal, and I found that the flat rate shipping charges (49 Eu no matter how many puzzles you buy) makes it worth it if you’re buying several, and you want to get the new collection faster and cheaper than you will eventually be able to buy them for locally.

    I placed an order for 22 puzzles from them last year, saved a few hundred dollars compared to US costs, and the service was fantastic. (Also, just 29 Eu for the 5000 piece Haasteren puzzles is insanely cheap, especially since they stock a few that are out of print.) I have no affiliation with them (I’m not even posting a link). I’m just a very satisfied customer.

    Great review. I’m looking forward to this one, but not as much as I’m looking forward to Carneval in Rio.

    • Thanks for the tip on puzzle-portal. I’ll check them out. Generally I’ve found that flat-rate shipping and buying in bulk is much cheaper when ordering from the UK or Europe.

      Jane

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Pingbacks & Trackbacks

  1. […] Knorr. Last year’s “Sherlock and Co” puzzle was one of my favorite of the year (see my review here). This one looks just as good or even better. I like the detailed line art and all the characters […]